Quality Filtering Skill

Overview

Implements the quality assessment logic used by the Quality Assessor agent. Provides reusable scoring heuristics, threshold configuration, and acceptance criteria for media content evaluation.

Title Keyword Scoring

Positive Quality Indicators

Pattern	Score Modifier	Match Examples	Confidence
`4K\|2160p`	+3	"4K Official", "2160p Pro Shot"	High
`1080p\|HD\|High Definition`	+2	"1080p HD", "High Definition"	High
`Pro Shot\|Professional`	+3	"Pro Shot Concert", "Professional Recording"	High
`Official\|Verified`	+2	"Official Music Video", "Verified Upload"	High
`Studio Session\|Soundboard\|Board Recording`	+3	"Studio Session Live", "Soundboard Audio"	High
`FLAC\|Lossless\|WAV\|ALAC`	+3	"FLAC Audio", "Lossless Recording"	High
`Remastered\|Restored\|Enhanced`	+2	"Remastered 2024", "Audio Restored"	Medium
`Multicam\|Multi-Camera`	+2	"Multicam Mix", "Multi-Camera Edit"	Medium
`60fps\|HFR`	+1	"60fps Smooth", "HFR Recording"	Medium

Negative Quality Indicators

Pattern	Score Modifier	Match Examples	Confidence
`phone\|mobile\|cell`	-4	"phone recording", "mobile upload"	High
`fan cam\|fancam\|audience`	-3	"fan cam row 20", "audience recording"	High
`crowd\|venue mic\|distant`	-2	"crowd recording", "distant mic"	Medium
`shaky\|unstable\|handheld`	-3	"shaky camera", "unstable footage"	High
`bad audio\|poor quality\|low quality`	-4	"bad audio sorry", "poor quality"	High
`240p\|360p\|potato`	-3	"240p upload", "potato quality"	High
`vertical\|portrait mode`	-2	"vertical video", "portrait mode"	High
`bootleg\|pirated\|ripped`	-1	"bootleg copy", "ripped from DVD"	Low
`compressed\|low bitrate`	-2	"compressed audio", "low bitrate"	Medium
`cropped\|zoomed\|partial`	-1	"cropped video", "zoomed in"	Medium

Scoring Implementation

function calculateTitleScore(title) {
  let score = 0;
  const normalizedTitle = title.toLowerCase();

  // Positive indicators
  const positivePatterns = [
    { regex: /4k|2160p/, modifier: 3 },
    { regex: /1080p|hd|high definition/, modifier: 2 },
    { regex: /pro shot|professional/, modifier: 3 },
    { regex: /official|verified/, modifier: 2 },
    { regex: /studio session|soundboard|board recording/, modifier: 3 },
    { regex: /flac|lossless|wav|alac/, modifier: 3 },
    { regex: /remastered|restored|enhanced/, modifier: 2 },
    { regex: /multicam|multi-camera/, modifier: 2 },
    { regex: /60fps|hfr/, modifier: 1 }
  ];

  // Negative indicators
  const negativePatterns = [
    { regex: /phone|mobile|cell/, modifier: -4 },
    { regex: /fan cam|fancam|audience/, modifier: -3 },
    { regex: /crowd|venue mic|distant/, modifier: -2 },
    { regex: /shaky|unstable|handheld/, modifier: -3 },
    { regex: /bad audio|poor quality|low quality/, modifier: -4 },
    { regex: /240p|360p|potato/, modifier: -3 },
    { regex: /vertical|portrait mode/, modifier: -2 },
    { regex: /bootleg|pirated|ripped/, modifier: -1 },
    { regex: /compressed|low bitrate/, modifier: -2 },
    { regex: /cropped|zoomed|partial/, modifier: -1 }
  ];

  // Apply positive modifiers
  for (const pattern of positivePatterns) {
    if (pattern.regex.test(normalizedTitle)) {
      score += pattern.modifier;
    }
  }

  // Apply negative modifiers
  for (const pattern of negativePatterns) {
    if (pattern.regex.test(normalizedTitle)) {
      score += pattern.modifier;
    }
  }

  return score;
}

Metadata Assessment Commands

Resolution Detection

# Extract video resolution
get_resolution() {
  local file="$1"
  ffprobe -v error -select_streams v:0 \
    -show_entries stream=width,height \
    -of csv=s=x:p=0 "$file"
}

# Score based on resolution
score_resolution() {
  local resolution="$1"
  local width height

  IFS='x' read -r width height <<< "$resolution"

  if [[ $width -ge 3840 ]]; then
    echo 10  # 4K+
  elif [[ $width -ge 1920 ]]; then
    echo 8   # 1080p
  elif [[ $width -ge 1280 ]]; then
    echo 6   # 720p
  elif [[ $width -ge 640 ]]; then
    echo 4   # 480p
  else
    echo 2   # <480p
  fi
}

Audio Bitrate Detection

# Extract audio bitrate
get_audio_bitrate() {
  local file="$1"
  ffprobe -v error -select_streams a:0 \
    -show_entries stream=bit_rate \
    -of default=noprint_wrappers=1:nokey=1 "$file"
}

# Score based on bitrate
score_audio_bitrate() {
  local bitrate="$1"

  if [[ $bitrate -ge 1000000 ]]; then
    echo 10  # Lossless (>1000kbps)
  elif [[ $bitrate -ge 256000 ]]; then
    echo 8   # High (256-320kbps)
  elif [[ $bitrate -ge 192000 ]]; then
    echo 6   # Medium (192-256kbps)
  elif [[ $bitrate -ge 128000 ]]; then
    echo 4   # Low (128-192kbps)
  else
    echo 2   # Very low (<128kbps)
  fi
}

Duration Sanity Check

# Extract duration in seconds
get_duration() {
  local file="$1"
  ffprobe -v error \
    -show_entries format=duration \
    -of default=noprint_wrappers=1:nokey=1 "$file"
}

# Validate duration makes sense
validate_duration() {
  local duration="$1"
  local expected_min="$2"  # Optional minimum duration
  local expected_max="$3"  # Optional maximum duration

  # Check duration is reasonable (>5 seconds, <12 hours)
  if (( $(echo "$duration < 5" | bc -l) )); then
    echo "ERROR: Duration too short ($duration seconds)"
    return 1
  elif (( $(echo "$duration > 43200" | bc -l) )); then
    echo "ERROR: Duration suspiciously long ($duration seconds)"
    return 1
  fi

  # Check against expected range if provided
  if [[ -n "$expected_min" ]] && (( $(echo "$duration < $expected_min" | bc -l) )); then
    echo "WARNING: Duration shorter than expected ($duration < $expected_min)"
  fi

  if [[ -n "$expected_max" ]] && (( $(echo "$duration > $expected_max" | bc -l) )); then
    echo "WARNING: Duration longer than expected ($duration > $expected_max)"
  fi

  return 0
}

Format Detection

# Detect audio codec
get_audio_codec() {
  local file="$1"
  ffprobe -v error -select_streams a:0 \
    -show_entries stream=codec_name \
    -of default=noprint_wrappers=1:nokey=1 "$file"
}

# Detect video codec
get_video_codec() {
  local file="$1"
  ffprobe -v error -select_streams v:0 \
    -show_entries stream=codec_name \
    -of default=noprint_wrappers=1:nokey=1 "$file"
}

# Score audio codec quality
score_audio_codec() {
  local codec="$1"

  case "$codec" in
    flac|alac|wav|ape)
      echo 10  # Lossless
      ;;
    aac|opus)
      echo 8   # Modern lossy (efficient)
      ;;
    mp3|vorbis)
      echo 6   # Standard lossy
      ;;
    *)
      echo 4   # Unknown/old codec
      ;;
  esac
}

Post-Download Verification

Audio Quality Analysis

# Analyze volume levels and detect clipping
analyze_audio_quality() {
  local file="$1"
  local tmpfile=$(mktemp)

  # Volume detection
  ffmpeg -i "$file" -af "volumedetect" -f null /dev/null 2>&1 | \
    grep -E "(mean_volume|max_volume)" > "$tmpfile"

  local mean_volume=$(grep "mean_volume" "$tmpfile" | awk '{print $5}')
  local max_volume=$(grep "max_volume" "$tmpfile" | awk '{print $5}')

  # Clipping detection
  local clipping=$(ffmpeg -i "$file" -af "astats=metadata=1:reset=1" \
    -f null /dev/null 2>&1 | grep -c "clipping")

  echo "mean_volume=$mean_volume"
  echo "max_volume=$max_volume"
  echo "clipping_samples=$clipping"

  rm "$tmpfile"

  # Score based on analysis
  if [[ $clipping -gt 100 ]]; then
    echo "WARNING: Significant clipping detected ($clipping samples)"
    return 2  # Poor quality due to clipping
  elif (( $(echo "$mean_volume < -30" | bc -l) )); then
    echo "WARNING: Very quiet audio (mean volume $mean_volume dB)"
    return 4  # Acceptable but quiet
  else
    return 8  # Good audio quality
  fi
}

Video Quality Analysis

# Detect interlacing (suggests old/poor source)
detect_interlacing() {
  local file="$1"

  ffmpeg -i "$file" -vf idet -frames:v 1000 -an -f null /dev/null 2>&1 | \
    grep "Multi frame detection"

  # If significant interlacing detected, likely old source
  if grep -q "TFF:\|BFF:" <<< "$(detect_interlacing "$file")"; then
    echo "WARNING: Interlaced video detected (likely old source)"
    return 4  # Lower score for interlaced
  else
    return 0  # No penalty
  fi
}

# Detect black bars (cropped/letterboxed source)
detect_black_bars() {
  local file="$1"

  local crop_params=$(ffmpeg -i "$file" -vf cropdetect -frames:v 100 \
    -an -f null /dev/null 2>&1 | tail -1 | grep -oP 'crop=\K[0-9:]+')

  echo "Suggested crop: $crop_params"

  # If suggested crop differs significantly from resolution, black bars exist
  # (Implementation would compare crop dimensions to actual resolution)
}

Quality Score Calculation

Weighted Scoring Function

function calculateQualityScore(audioScore, videoScore, uniquenessScore, contentType) {
  let weights;

  if (contentType === 'audio-only') {
    weights = {
      audio: 1.0,
      video: 0.0,
      uniqueness: 0.3,
      total: 1.3
    };
  } else {  // video content
    weights = {
      audio: 0.6,
      video: 0.3,
      uniqueness: 0.3,
      total: 1.2
    };
  }

  const weightedScore = (
    (weights.audio * audioScore) +
    (weights.video * videoScore) +
    (weights.uniqueness * uniquenessScore)
  ) / weights.total;

  return {
    audio: audioScore,
    video: videoScore,
    uniqueness: uniquenessScore,
    weighted: weightedScore,
    verdict: determineVerdict(weightedScore, uniquenessScore)
  };
}

function determineVerdict(score, uniqueness) {
  // Legendary content overrides quality threshold
  if (uniqueness >= 10) {
    return {
      decision: 'ACCEPT',
      reason: 'Legendary content override'
    };
  }

  // Apply configurable threshold (default 6.0)
  const threshold = process.env.QUALITY_THRESHOLD || 6.0;

  if (score >= threshold) {
    return {
      decision: 'ACCEPT',
      reason: `Quality score ${score.toFixed(1)} meets threshold ${threshold}`
    };
  } else {
    return {
      decision: 'REJECT',
      reason: `Quality score ${score.toFixed(1)} below threshold ${threshold}`
    };
  }
}

Threshold Configuration

Configuration File Format

# quality-thresholds.yaml
quality:
  default_threshold: 6.0

  thresholds:
    conservative: 8.0   # "Only the best"
    balanced: 6.0       # Default
    permissive: 3.0     # "I want everything"

  weights:
    audio_only:
      audio: 1.0
      video: 0.0
      uniqueness: 0.3

    video_content:
      audio: 0.6
      video: 0.3
      uniqueness: 0.3

  overrides:
    legendary_content: true   # Accept any quality if legendary
    user_request: true        # Accept if explicitly requested
    official_source: false    # Don't auto-accept official (still assess quality)

Dynamic Threshold Adjustment

function adjustThreshold(userPreference, storageAvailable) {
  const baseThreshold = 6.0;

  // User preference modifier
  let threshold = baseThreshold;
  switch (userPreference) {
    case 'conservative':
      threshold = 8.0;
      break;
    case 'permissive':
      threshold = 3.0;
      break;
    default:
      threshold = baseThreshold;
  }

  // Storage-based adjustment
  if (storageAvailable < 10) {  // Less than 10GB available
    console.warn('Low storage: Increasing quality threshold by 1.0');
    threshold += 1.0;
  }

  return threshold;
}

Uniqueness Assessment

Rarity Determination Heuristics

function assessUniqueness(metadata) {
  const { title, channel, uploadDate, views, searchResults } = metadata;

  // Check for explicit rarity claims in title
  const rarityKeywords = {
    legendary: /first.*recording|last.*show|unreleased|lost.*media|only.*known/i,
    rare: /rare|pre-fame|demo|early.*version|bootleg/i,
    uncommon: /special.*guest|unique.*arrangement|live.*debut/i
  };

  for (const [level, pattern] of Object.entries(rarityKeywords)) {
    if (pattern.test(title)) {
      return {
        level,
        reason: `Title indicates ${level} content`,
        confidence: 'medium'
      };
    }
  }

  // Assess based on search results (how many similar recordings exist)
  if (searchResults <= 1) {
    return { level: 'legendary', reason: 'Only known recording', confidence: 'high' };
  } else if (searchResults <= 5) {
    return { level: 'rare', reason: 'Very few recordings available', confidence: 'high' };
  } else if (searchResults <= 15) {
    return { level: 'uncommon', reason: 'Limited recordings available', confidence: 'medium' };
  } else if (searchResults <= 50) {
    return { level: 'common', reason: 'Many recordings available', confidence: 'medium' };
  } else {
    return { level: 'redundant', reason: 'Abundant recordings available', confidence: 'high' };
  }
}

Integration Examples

Pre-Download Assessment

// Assess before downloading to save bandwidth
async function preDownloadAssessment(videoMetadata) {
  const titleScore = calculateTitleScore(videoMetadata.title);
  const uniqueness = await assessUniqueness(videoMetadata);

  // Estimate quality based on available metadata
  const estimatedAudioScore = estimateAudioFromMetadata(videoMetadata);
  const estimatedVideoScore = estimateVideoFromMetadata(videoMetadata);

  const qualityScore = calculateQualityScore(
    estimatedAudioScore,
    estimatedVideoScore,
    uniqueness.score,
    videoMetadata.contentType
  );

  if (qualityScore.verdict.decision === 'REJECT') {
    console.log(`Skipping download: ${qualityScore.verdict.reason}`);
    return false;
  }

  console.log(`Proceeding with download: Quality score ${qualityScore.weighted.toFixed(1)}`);
  return true;
}

Post-Download Verification

# Verify downloaded file meets quality standards
verify_download() {
  local file="$1"

  # Extract metadata
  local resolution=$(get_resolution "$file")
  local audio_bitrate=$(get_audio_bitrate "$file")
  local duration=$(get_duration "$file")

  # Analyze quality
  local audio_quality=$(analyze_audio_quality "$file")
  local video_score=$(score_resolution "$resolution")
  local audio_score=$(score_audio_bitrate "$audio_bitrate")

  echo "Resolution: $resolution (score: $video_score)"
  echo "Audio bitrate: $audio_bitrate (score: $audio_score)"
  echo "Duration: $duration seconds"
  echo "Audio quality analysis: $audio_quality"

  # Final verdict
  if [[ $audio_score -ge 6 && $video_score -ge 6 ]]; then
    echo "VERIFIED: File meets quality standards"
    return 0
  else
    echo "QUALITY WARNING: File below quality threshold"
    return 1
  fi
}

References

@$AIWG_ROOT/agentic/code/addons/aiwg-utils/rules/research-before-decision.md — Evaluate quality metadata before making accept/reject decisions
@$AIWG_ROOT/agentic/code/frameworks/media-curator/skills/find-sources/SKILL.md — Source discovery that uses quality scoring to rank discovered sources
@$AIWG_ROOT/agentic/code/frameworks/media-curator/skills/acquire/SKILL.md — Acquisition skill that applies quality filtering before downloading
@$AIWG_ROOT/agentic/code/frameworks/media-curator/skills/integrity-verification/SKILL.md — Integrity verification used as a post-download quality check

Quality Filtering Skill

Overview

Title Keyword Scoring

Positive Quality Indicators

Negative Quality Indicators

Scoring Implementation

Metadata Assessment Commands

Resolution Detection

Audio Bitrate Detection

Duration Sanity Check

Format Detection

Post-Download Verification

Audio Quality Analysis

Video Quality Analysis

Quality Score Calculation

Weighted Scoring Function

Threshold Configuration

Configuration File Format

Dynamic Threshold Adjustment

Uniqueness Assessment

Rarity Determination Heuristics

Integration Examples

Pre-Download Assessment

Post-Download Verification

See Also

References